[mamaemmot]

hubby is asking for SCIENTIFIC proof as to why NOT to vaccinate.  without that he isn't really willing to NOT vaccinate this next baby.  please help...    thanks

[mamaemmot]

hubby is asking for SCIENTIFIC proof as to why NOT to vaccinate.  without that he isn't really willing to NOT vaccinate this next baby.  please help...    thanks

[witch_power]

If he was my husband, I would be asking him to provide scientific proof that vaccines are safe.

But I will post the studies I find as I come across them...

“Rotavirus vaccine cuts deaths of Mexican babies from diarrhoea by 40%," states a January, 2010, British Medical Journal headline summarizing two studies.(1) Yet, a study of Brazilian children finds that exclusive breastfeeding cuts diarrhea cases in this similarly developing nation by a whopping 90% (1 / 9.41), versus a diet of formula and/or other foods.(2)

A study on the cost of breastfeeding promotion programs for Brazil and Mexico accounted a 30 to 40 cent cost per birth for breastfeeding promotion programs.(3) The vaccine costs $190 for a series of 3 oral Rotovirus doses. The vaccine also leads to a substantial increase in cases of intussusception, a dangerous intestinal condition where part of the intestine folds in, inside itself. Treatment costs and lives lost from this side effect of the vaccine should be considered as well.


For more on the many ways breastfeeding acts as the ultimate 'vaccine' against all of infant (and later life) maladies, see Palmer's excellent book, The Baby Bond.


References:

1 A. Gutland, “Rotavirus vaccine cuts deaths of Mexican babies from diarrhoea by 40%,” BMJ 2010 Jan 28, doi:10.1136/bmj.c511.

2. H.S. Maranhão, et al., “The epidemiological and clinical characteristics and nutritional development of infants with acute diarrhoea, in north-eastern Brazil,” Ann Trop Med Parasitol, 2008 Jun;102(4):357-65.

3. S. Horton, et al., “Breastfeeding promotion and priority setting in health,” Health Policy Plan, 1996 Jun;11(2):156-68.

[catherina]

count me in on "Team Husband"

[catherina]

Brazil and Mexico, really? In both countries, this may be an article pro-breastfeeding, but not necessarily against the rotavirus vaccine. Do you have anything along these lines from the US or Western Europe?

[witch_power]

I will keep looking, I know there have been a ton of studies, but I don't have a lot of time to look.

I did start looking on the sites against vaccines, but I wanted to find something less biased.